• Top Posts

  • Fair Use Notice

    This blog may contain copyrighted material. Such material is made available for educational purposes, to advance understanding of human rights, democracy, scientific, moral, ethical, and social justice issues, ecological rights, human interaction with nature, etc. This constitutes a ‘fair use’ of any such copyrighted material as provided for in Title 17 U.S.C. section 107 of the US Copyright Law. This material is distributed without profit.
  • RSS The Consumerist

    • BlueHippo Files Chapter 11 After Bank Accounts Frozen November 29, 2009
      It appears that when the FTC filed a contempt charge against scamtastic consumer electronics purveyor Bluehippo, the company's bank took notice and froze their accounts. Now Bluehippo has filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection, claiming that they can't repay their creditors, what with the frozen bank accounts and all. This will not end well. If […]
      Laura Northrup
    • Best Buy Holds Discounted Netbook, Delights Customer November 28, 2009
      A story about a great customer service experience at Best Buy? On Black Friday? It doesn't seem possible. And yet, it happened to Brian and Briana when they shopped the early sale for Silver Reward Zone members. Brian tells us: It started when Best Buy announced "early" access to Black Friday prices for all Silver Reward Zone members. Since my […]
      Laura Northrup
    • Delta Air Lines: You Need To Pay A Fee To Pay This Fee November 28, 2009
      Martin's 5-year-old stepdaughter has had a very eventful holiday week. So has her family. Flying as an unaccompanied minor, she had to miss her original flight on AirTran and her family booked another at the last minute. The first reasonably priced flight available was on NWA/Delta, but her parents tell us that communication between different department […]
      Laura Northrup
    • Buy A Mattress, Get A Free Video Camera November 28, 2009
      A few weeks ago, Macy's ran this somewhat mystifying promotion. Simple enough: Buy a mattress, get a free video camera via mail-in rebate. It's interesting to see a department store modern enough to openly market to aspiring amateur porn stars. You know it's an authentic Macy's promotion because the fine print is much longer than the ad i […]
      Laura Northrup
    • Duck Tape Determined To Make Up For Defective Roll November 28, 2009
      "Above and Beyond" stories can come from the most mundane sources. Such as this e-mail that reader MJ sent in praise of the customer service for Duck Tape brand duct tape. I recently had an issue with a roll of Duck Tape that ended up being bad. I bought a 2 pack of the better grade and it just wouldn't stick like I think it should. I looked u […]
      Laura Northrup

The Liars Club by Mary Karr- Take 2

There is a moment in the opening of the second half, where I am suddenly aware of the fact taht Karr is telling me a story. So often I forgot that during the first half, mostly because I didn’t find anything she said that unrealisitic.
They’ve just moved to Colorado and the family awakens to a bear rummaging through the trash. Her father “barks” at the bear trying to scare it off and in doing so only agitates it. I had this image of the father and the bear facing off in the yard and it seemed as far fetched as the story of her father and uncle cutting the house in half. It interests me where she juxtaposes her own story telling with her father’s.
Later she even says “I think Daddy would be proud of my telling” commenting on her own story telling ability.
And then within the last few pages:”Few born liars ever intentionally embark in truths direction, even those who believe that sucha a journey might axiomatically set them free,” which is exactly what I think she does. Anyone who writes knows how sometimes the story writes itself. Little details that aren’t folded into your memory somehow end up on the page. Sometimes stories come out in a way that fixes the problem in your head, even though you arent entirely devoted to the “truth.” I think Karr does a fantastic job of acknowledging that all of these things are her truth. This version of her history is the best way she knew how to convey her story and the best way to execute her own catharsis. I love how she ends the book with reflections on her own story telling.
Karr is bright, honest and refreshing to read. My pleasure.

One Response

  1. Candice,
    I’m also fascinated by her self-awareness of storytelling and the ways in which stories themselves function throughout this book. It makes me think even more about her father’s Liars’ Club–the tall tales, the exaggeration, the fabrications. I wonder if–in contrast to those stories–her real stories don’t seem so farfetched anymore. We may shudder as we read, but she’s really provided a scale of truth (and lies) with her text and that teaches us where to place all the stories she’s telling.

Leave a Reply